- Griddle or grill?
- Different jobs. A grate sears, drains fat away and gives you a hot side and a cool side. A flat top catches everything a grate drops: eggs, smash burgers, diced onions. It cannot run an indirect zone, so it adds to a grill rather than replacing one.
- Pellet, charcoal or offset for low and slow?
- A pellet grill holds a set point for hours without you touching it, which is why it wins for overnight cooks and for anyone who wants to sleep. Charcoal gives more smoke flavor and costs you attention, because you are managing vents and fuel the whole time. An offset gives the most control and the most work. Pick by how much of the cook you actually want to be present for.
- How big a grill do I actually need?
- Count the people you cook for on a normal weekend, not the once-a-year party. Compare primary grate area rather than total cooking area, because the total usually folds in a warming rack and a warming rack will not take a burger.
- Propane, natural gas or charcoal?
- Propane goes anywhere and you refill tanks. Natural gas never runs out mid cook but ties the grill to a fixed supply and needs a line run by a licensed fitter. Charcoal costs you the wait and gives you heat and smoke that gas does not. Where the grill will stand usually settles this before any spec does.